Author, year | Age (years) | Gender | Chronic symptoms | Small bowel obstruction | Left paraduodenal hernia confirmed on imaging | Emergency/ elective surgery | Laparotomy | Laparoscopic |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chatterjee et al., 2012[11] | 55 | Male | - | Yes | - | Emergency | Yes | - |
Bhatti et al., 2012[12] | 18 | Female | - | Yes | - | Emergency | Yes | - |
Akbulut et al., 2012[13] | 42 | Male | - | Yes | - | Emergency | Yes | - |
Hussein et al. 2012[14] | 59 | Female | - | Yes | Yes | Emergency | - | Yes |
Fernandez-Ray et al. 2011[15] | 39 | Male | - | Yes | Yes | Emergency | Yes | - |
Downes et al., 2010[16] | 47 | Male | Yes | - | - | Emergency | Yes | - |
Parmar et al.,2010[17] | 38 | Male | Yes | - | - | Elective | - | Yes |
Khalaileh et al., 2010[5] | 53 | Female | - | Yes | Yes | Emergency | - | yes |
Yun et al., 2010[18] | 28 | Male | - | - | Yes | Emergency | Yes | - |
Uchiyam et al., 2009[19] | 80 | Female | Yes | - | - | Elective | - | Yes |
Poultsides et al., 2009[20] | 67 | Female | - | Yes | - | Emergency | - | Yes |
Kuzinkovas et al., 2008[21] | 59 | Male | - | - | - | Elective | Yes | - |
Peters et al., 2008[22] | 76 | Male | - | Yes | Yes | Emergency | Yes | - |
Jeong et al., 2008[23] | 52 | Male | - | Yes | - | Emergency | - | Yes |
Jeong et al., 2008[23] | 58 | Female | - | Yes | - | Emergency | - | Yes |
Palanivelu et al., 2008[24] | - | Male | - | - | Yes | Elective | - | Yes |
Palanivelu et al., 2008[24] | - | Male | - | Yes | Yes | Emergency | - | Yes |
Palanivelu et al., 2008[24] | - | Female | - | Yes | Yes | Elective | - | Yes |
Shoji et al., 2007[25] | 60 | Male | - | - | - | Emergency | - | Yes |
Papaziogas et al., 2007[26] | 35 | Female | - | Yes | - | Emergency | Yes | - |
Moon et al., 2006[27] | 18 | Male | - | Yes | - | Emergency | - | Yes |
Brehm et al. 2006[28] | 54 | Female | Yes | - | Yes | Emergency | Yes | - |
Thoma et al., 2006[29] | 72 | Female | Yes | - | - | Elective | Yes | - |
Cingi et al., 2006[30] | 30 | Male | Yes | - | - | Emergency | Yes | - |
Kurachi et al., 2006[31] | 47 | Female | - | Yes | - | Emergency | Yes | - |
Huang et al., 2005[32] | 24 | Male | Yes | Yes | - | Emergency | Yes | - |
Ovali et al., 2005[33] | 52 | Female | Yes | - | Yes | Refused surgery | - | - |
Fukunaga et al., 2004[34] | 51 | Male | Yes | Yes | Yes | Emergency | - | Yes |
Rollins et al., 2004[35] | 21 | Male | Yes | - | Yes | Elective | - | Yes |
Patti et al., 2004[36] | 46 | Male | Yes | - | - | Elective | Yes | - |
Catalano et al., 2004[37] | 82 | Male | - | Yes | Yes | Emergency | Yes | - |
Goodney et al., 2004[38] | 75 | Male | Yes | - | - | Elective | Yes | - |
Tong et al., 2002[39] | 30 | Male | Yes | - | - | Elective | Yes | - |
Nishida et al., 2001[40] | 47 | Male | Yes | - | Yes | Elective | Yes | Yes |
Patil et al., 1999[41] | 29 | Female | - | - | Yes | Emergency | Yes | - |
Schaffler et al., 1999[42] | 26 | Male | Yes | - | Yes | Elective | Yes | - |
Uematsu et al., 1998[43] | 44 | Male | Yes | - | - | Elective | - | Yes |
Hirasaki et al., 1998[44] | 28 | Female | Yes | - | Yes | Elective | Yes | - |
Mcdonagh et al., 1996[45] | 52 | Male | - | Yes | - | Emergency | Yes | - |
Suchato et al., 1996[46] | 40 | Male | - | Yes | - | Emergency | Yes | - |
Suchato et al., 1996[46] | 52 | Male | Yes | - | - | Emergency | Yes | - |
Warshauer et al., 1992[47] | 42 | Female | Yes | - | Yes | Elective | Yes | - |
Toit et al., 1986[48] | 22 | Male | - | Yes | - | Emergency | Yes | - |
Tireli et al., 1982[49] | 18 | Male | - | Yes | - | Emergency | Yes | - |