Skip to main content

Table 4 US versus non-US intra-rater agreement

From: Regional variability in use of a novel assessment of thoracolumbar spine fractures: United States versus international surgeons

 

Percent Agreement

Cohen's Kappa

Weighted Kappa

Spearman's Rank Order

 

Mechanism

USA

62.2*

0.454

0.465

0.561

Non-USA

56.0

0.398

0.519

0.605

 

Neurological Status

USA

87.6

0.781

0.803

0.825

Non-USA

96.2*

0.933

0.956

0.982*

 

PLC Integrity

USA

67.4

0.455

0.519

0.578

Non-USA

69.7

0.507

0.610

0.685*

 

Total TLISS

USA

43.3

0.354

0.588

0.726

Non-USA

41.4

0.342

0.658

0.825*

 

Management

USA

78.8

0.617

0.582

0.604

Non-USA

77.6

0.610

0.577

0.609

  1. Intra-Rater agreement within USA and non-USA surgeons.
  2. *p < 0.05 for difference between USA and non-USA surgeons. For significance tests, all unweighted coefficients were converted into Fisher's z-scores, and the difference in z-scores was divided by standard error.
  3. A level was set at 0.05 (ΔZ/SE ≥ 1.96).