Skip to main content

Table 2 Studies’ characteristics

From: Laparoscopic lavage versus resection in perforated diverticulitis with purulent peritonitis: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

Study

Year

Country

Study design

Inclusion criteria

Exclusion criteria

Primary outcome

Sample size

Elegible patients

Analysis

Enrolled patients

Laparoscopic drainage

Bowel resection

Study quality

Limits

DILALA

2010–2014

Sweden, Denmark

multicentric RCT

patients with Hinchey III diverticulitis at diagnostic laparoscopy

not reported

reoperation at 12 months

64

not reported

ITT

83

43

40

High

 

SCANDIV

2010–2014

Sweden, Norway

multicentric RCT

patients with free air at abdominal CT scan

obstruction pregnancy

severe complications and death at 90 days

130

216

modified ITT

144a

74a

70a

High

includes also patients with Hinchey I-II

LADIES

2010–2013

Belgium, Netherlands, Italy

multicentric RCT

patients with Hinchey III diverticulitis at diagnostic laparoscopy

dementia, previous abdominal irradiation, high dose steroidal therapy, shock, age >85

severe complications and mortality at 12 months

264

241

ITT

88

46

42

High

premature ending

  1. a subgroup analysis of patients with Hinchey grade I-II-III diverticulitis