Population | Inclusion criteria | Scores tested | Outcome 1 | Outcome 2 (if applicable) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Ward or ED (n = 380) Szakmany 2017 [39] | NEWS ≥ 3 | 30-day mortality | Organ dysfunction | |
Sepsis-1 | 68% SENS | |||
Sepsis-3 | 86% SENS | |||
qSOFA ≥ 2 | 22% SENS | 26% SENS | ||
SOFA | 0.70 AUC | 86% SENS | ||
SIRS | 26% SENS | |||
Sepsis-1 (severe) | 92% SENS | |||
NEWS > 6 | 41% SENS | 36% SENS | ||
0.59 AUC | ||||
Post-operative ICU patients [44] (n = 50) | Peritonitis + IAS requiring ICU | Multivariate Prediction of in-hospital death | ||
APACHE II | HR 6.7 [95CI 2.7–17] | |||
MPI | HR 9.8 095CI 1.3–73] | |||
SAPS | NS | |||
SSS | NS | |||
MOF | NS | |||
Ranson | NS | |||
Imrie | NS | |||
Predictions of death (day 1 SICU) | ||||
Post-operative SICU patients (n = 145) Delibegovic 2011 [37] | Non-traumatic secondary peritonitis requiring laparotomy | TISS-28 | AUC 0.87 | |
APACHE II | AUC 0.86 | |||
MODS | AUC 0.83 | |||
SAPS | AUC 0.83 | |||
MPI | AUC 0.72 | |||
SSS | AUC 0.70 | |||
Abdominal septic shock in ICU (n = 382) Hanisch 2011 [47] | Sepsis-1 criteria [61] for abdominal septic shock | SOFA | Death prediction first 3 ICU days | 0.54 AUC |
APACHE II | 0.52 AUC | |||
SAPS | 0.52 AUC | |||
MODS | 0.52 AUC | |||
IAS pts requiring SCL (n = 211) Chan [48] | SCL and severe sepsis or septic shock as per Sepsis-1 (61) | APACHE-IV | Predicted mortality rate | 0.67 AUC |
IAS pts requiting re-laparotomy (n = 34) Das [32] | Secondary peritonitis | APACHE-II | Hospital mortality prediction | 0.958 AUC |
SAPS-II | 0.955 AUC | |||
P-POSSUM | 0.931 AUC | |||
IAS pts undergoing SCL (n = 221) Van Ruler [50] | APACHE > 10 | Mortality | Need for Re-Laparotomy | |
APACHE-II | 0.74 AUC | 0.49 AUC | ||
SAPS-II | 0.80 AUC | 0.56 AUC | ||
MPI | 0.60 AUC | 0.52 AUC | ||
SOFA | 0.72 AUC | 0.55 AUC | ||
MODS | 0.76 AUC | 0.55 AUC | ||
APS | 0.68 AUC | .60 AUC |