Skip to main content

Table 4 Overall video quality assessment (good, moderate, or poor) by senior surgeons and novice trainees in digestive surgery

From: Educational value of surgical videos on YouTube: quality assessment of laparoscopic appendectomy videos by senior surgeons vs. novice trainees

Number Senior surgeons Novice trainees
Video quality examiner 1 Video quality examiner 2 Video quality examiner 3 Video quality examiner 4 Video quality examiner 5 Video quality examiner 6
1 Moderate Moderate Poor Moderate Poor Moderate
2 Good Good Good Good Good Good
3 Moderate Moderate Moderate Good Good Good
4 Moderate Moderate Good Poor Moderate Moderate
5 Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate
6 Poor Poor Moderate Moderate Poor Poor
7 Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate Poor Moderate
8 Poor Poor Moderate Good Poor Poor
9 Poor Poor Poor Poor Moderate Moderate
10 Poor Poor Poor Poor Poor Poor
11 Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate Poor
12 Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate Good Moderate
13 Moderate Moderate Moderate Good Good Moderate
14 Poor Poor Poor Moderate Moderate Moderate
15 Moderate Moderate Moderate Poor Moderate Poor
16 Poor Poor Good Moderate Good Moderate
17 Good Good Good Good Good Moderate
18 Moderate Moderate Good Good Good Moderate
19 Poor Poor Poor Poor Good Moderate
20 Poor Poor Moderate Good Good Moderate
21 Moderate Moderate Moderate Good Good Moderate
22 Poor Poor Poor Poor Poor Moderate
23 Poor Poor Poor Moderate Moderate Moderate
24 Poor Poor Poor Poor Poor Poor
25 Poor Poor Poor Moderate Moderate Moderate