Table 1 Kind of treatment of perforated duodenal diverticulum reported in medical literature
Author | Pz | Duodenal portion | Year | Kind of treatment performed | Type of treatment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Surgical | Non-surgical | |||||
Thorson CM et al. [11] | 4 | II portion | 2012 | Non operative management | Bowel rest antibiotics | |
Metcalfe MJ et al. [24] | 1 | II portion | 2010 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulectomy | |
Gottschalk U et al. [25] | 1 | II portion | 2010 | Endoscopical treatment | ||
Lee HH et al. [23] | 1 | II portion | 2010 | Surgical treatment | Laparoscopic Diverticulectomy | |
Volchok J et al. [26] | 1 | II portion | 2009 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulectomy | |
Lopez-Zarraga F et al. [27] | 1 | II portion | 2009 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulectomy | |
Ames JT et al. [28] | 8 | II portion | 2009 | Surgical treatment and nonoperative management | NR | Bowel rest antibiotics |
III portion | ||||||
Guinier D et al. [29] | 1 | II portion | 2008 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulectomy | NR |
Schnueriger B et al. [10] | 5 | II Portion | 2008 | Surgical treatment and nonoperative management | -Segmental duodenectomy | PTC tube, Bowel rest, Antibiotics |
III Portion | ||||||
IV Portion | ||||||
-Pylorus-preserving duodeno-pancreatectomy (pp-Whipple) | ||||||
-Diverticulectomy | ||||||
Martinez-Cecilia D et al. [19] | 1 | II Portion | 2008 | Conservative treatment | NR | Bowel Rest, Antibiotics and percutaneous drainage |
Huang RY et al. [20] | 1 | II Portion | 2007 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulectomy | NR |
Hirota S et al. [30] | 1 | II portion | 2007 | Surgical treatment | NR | NR |
Andromanakos N et al. [31] | 1 | II Portion | 2007 | Surgical treatment | Subtotal gastrectomy and antecolic anastomosis and retroperitoneal drainage | NR |
Valenzuela Martínez MJ et al. [32] | 1 | II Portion | 2006 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulectomy | |
Safioleas M et al. [33] | 1 | II portion | 2006 | Surgical treatment | Gastrojejunostomy, drenage | |
Castellví J et al. [34] | 1 | III Portion | 2006 | Surgical treatment | Gastroenteroanastomosis and biliary drainage with Kehr, gastrojejunostomy | NR |
Miller G et al. [8] | 3 | II Portion | 2005 | Surgical treatment and nonoperative management | Diverticulectomy, diversion (pyloric exclusion, gastrojejunostomy) | Antibiotics, bowel rest |
III Portion | ||||||
Papalambros E et al. [35] | 1 | III Portion | 2005 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulectomy and duodenostomy at the second duodenal portion | |
Lee VT et al. [36] | 1 | II Portion | 2005 | Surgical treatment | Roux -en- Y duodenojejunostomy. | |
Bergman S et al. [22] | 1 | II portion | 2005 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulectomy and duodenotomy | |
Marhin WW et al. [37] | 2 | II portion | 2005 | Surgical and conservative treatment | Diverticulectomy | Antibiotics therapy |
Yokomuro S et al. [7] | 1 | II portion | 2004 | Surgical treatment | Primary closure with drainage | |
Sakurai Y et al. [6] | 1 | II portion | 2004 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulectomy | |
Yarze JC et al. [38] | 1 | II portion | 2002 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulectomy | |
Franzen D et al. [16] | 1 | II portion | 2002 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulectomy | |
Atmani A et al. [39] | 2 | II portion | 2002 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulectomy lateral duodenostomy, T tube | |
Gulotta G et al. [40] | 1 | II portion | 2001 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulo-jejunostomy on a Roux-en-Y | |
Eeckhout G et al. [41] | 1 | II portion | 2000 | Percutaneous and endoscopic management | ||
Tsukamoto T et al. [42] | 2 | II portion | 1999 | Surgical treatment and nonoperative management | Diverticulectomy | Antibiotics, percutaneous abscess drainage. |
Rao PM et al. [15] | 1 | III portion | 1999 | Surgical treatment | NR | |
Poostizadeh A et al. [43] | 1 | III portion | 1997 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulectomy, Gastrostomy | |
Ido K et al. [44] | 1 | II portion | 1997 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulectomy | |
Cavanagh JE et al. [45] | 1 | II portion | 1996 | Surgical treatment | Malecot drainage in diverticulum | |
Mehdi A et al. [46] | 2 | II portion | 1994 | Surgical treatment | Diverticulectomy | |
III portion | ||||||
Guglielmi A et al. [47] | 2 | II portion | 1993 | Surgical treatment | Diverticuletomy, diversion | |
Pugash RA et al. [48] | 2 | II portion | 1990 | Surgical treatment | Aspiration, drainage, T tube | |
Steinman E et al. [49] | 2 | II portion | 1989 | Surgical treatment | Drainage | |
III portion | ||||||
Beech RR et al. [50] | 1 | II portion | 1985 | Surgical treatment | Tube duodenostomy | |
Stebbings WS et al. [51] | 2 | I portion | 1985 | Surgical treatment | Diverticuletomy, primary closure with drainage | |