Skip to main content

Table 8 Evidence about primary resection with anastomosis vs Hartmann’s procedure

From: A historical review of surgery for peritonitis secondary to acute colonic diverticulitis: from Lockhart-Mummery to evidence-based medicine

  Study type Cases Pathology Hinchey stage
Hinchey </= 2 Hinchey > 2
PRA HP PRA HP PRA HP
Hold et al. (1990) R 99 76 DD, P, A 83 45 16 31
Gooszen et al. (2001) R 32 28 DD, P, A 11 9 21 19
Schilling et al. (2001) PNR 13 42 DD, P 0 0 13 42
Regenet et al. (2003) PNR 27 33 DD, P 0 0 27 33
Richter et. Al (2006) PNR 36 5 DD, P 0 0 36 5
Trenti et al. (2011) R 27 60 P 0 0 58 69
Oberkofler et al. (2012) RCT 32 30 (DD) P 0 0 32 30
Alanis et al. (1989) R 34 26 DD,P,A 31 19 3 7
Alizai (2013) R 26 72 DD,P,A 16 24 10 48
Blair (2002) R 33 634 DD,P,A 24 31 9 32
Berry (1989) R 27 47 DD,P,A,O,F,B NR NR NR NR
Gawlick (2012) R 340 1678 DD,P,A NR NR NR NR
Herzog (2011) R 21 19 DD,P,A,O,B NR NR NR NR
Kourtesis (1988) R 23 10 DD,P,A, F NR 6 0 4
Mäkelä (2005) R 64 93 DD,P 62 19 2 0
Mueller (2011) R 47 26 DD,P,A 45 14 2 12
Pastenak (2010) R 46 65 DD,P,A 34 17 12 48
Saccomani (1993) R 26 8 DD,P,A,F NR NR NR NR
Smirniotis (1992) R 6 18 DD,P,A 6 10 0 8
Stumpf (2007) R 36 30 DD,P,A,O NR NR NR NR
Tabbara (2010) R 18 176 DD,P,A,S 16 69 2 107
Zingg et al. (2009) PNR 46 65 DD, P 34 17 12 48
Binda et al. (2012) RCT 34 56 P 0 0 34 56
Tudor (1994) PNR 76 77 DD,P,A,B,O,F 29 20 8 44
Vermeulen (2007) R 61 139 DD,P,A 35 44 26 95
  1. RCT randomized controlled trial, PNR prospective, nonrandomized, R retrospective
  2. PRA primary resection and anastomosis, HP Hartmann’s operation
  3. Pathology: P peritonitis, A abscess, O obstruction, DD diverticular disease
  4. F fistula, B bleeding (dc chronic diverticulitis)